Clear, golden and permanently runny? Not necessarily. From crystallisation and changing colour to differences between one harvest and the next, some of the things consumers question about honey can simply be part of its natural variation.
A jar of honey has been sitting in the cupboard for a while. It was clear and runny when you bought it, but now it has become cloudy, thicker and grainy. Do you throw it away?
Not always.
Crystallisation is one of the most visible changes that can happen to honey, yet it is also one that consumers can easily mistake for something having gone wrong.
“Crystallisation is not a sign of spoiled or adulterated honey; it is a natural biological process that occurs in pure, raw honey,” says Danie Vorster, beekeeper and co-founder of South African honey producer Hive & Earth.
It is not the only expectation about honey that may need reconsidering.
Consumers have become familiar with jars that look remarkably consistent: clear, golden, sweet and easy to pour. But honey is an agricultural product, and its colour, flavour, aroma and texture can vary according to what bees have been foraging on and the conditions surrounding a particular harvest.
That means two jars of genuine honey do not necessarily have to look or taste identical.
Why does honey crystallise?
Crystallisation is a natural process in which some of the sugars in honey form crystals, changing its texture and appearance. How quickly this happens can vary considerably between different honeys.
One of the factors influencing this is the natural balance between glucose and fructose. Honeys with a relatively higher glucose content tend to crystallise more readily, while those with relatively more fructose may remain fluid for longer. Temperature and the presence of naturally occurring particles such as pollen can also influence the process.
For consumers, the important distinction is that crystallisation on its own does not mean a jar of honey is spoiled.
For Hive & Earth, allowing honey to retain its natural variation is part of preserving the differences between individual harvests, rather than trying to make every jar look and taste exactly the same.
Vorster believes expectations around consistency have helped create confusion about what honey is supposed to look like.
Why can one honey taste different from another?
Bees forage on the flowers available around their hive, meaning the plants flowering within that landscape influence the nectar they collect.
In the Western Cape’s fynbos, for example, bees may have access to different combinations of indigenous flowering plants depending on the area, season and conditions.
Fynbos honey is therefore not necessarily the product of one flower. It can reflect a changing combination of plants flowering within foraging distance of a colony at a particular time.
“The beekeeper does not create the flavour; the bees and the landscape do,” says Vorster.
Even honey harvested from the same general area can vary between seasons because nature does not produce exactly the same flowering conditions year after year.
Rainfall, temperature, the timing and abundance of flowering, and the plants available to bees can all contribute to differences between harvests.
It is why Liana van Rensburg, co-founder of Hive & Earth, describes honey as more than simply something sweet.
“True honey is not merely a sweetener. It is a living record of a landscape.”
Does darker or lighter honey mean one is better?
Colour alone should not be treated as a simple measure of whether one honey is better than another.
Natural honey can range considerably in colour, and differences between jars can reflect the nectar sources available to the bees and the characteristics of a particular harvest.
The same applies to flavour. Some honeys may be delicate, while others have a much more pronounced taste. Variation does not automatically mean inconsistency in the way consumers might understand it with a manufactured food product.
It can simply mean the bees were working in a different place, at a different time, with different plants in flower.
Why does processing matter?
What happens after honey leaves the hive can also influence what eventually reaches the jar.
Hive & Earth says its approach is to follow individual harvests from the apiary through extraction and bottling, rather than buying bulk honey at the end of the process.
“We are not honey traders who buy and repackage bulk liquids,” says Vorster. “We are beekeepers, and our mission is to re-educate the palate on what genuine, unadulterated honey is meant to be.”
The company extracts in small batches at its own facility and keeps distinctive regional harvests separate, with jars traceable to their harvest area, apiary and extraction batch.
Van Rensburg says that involvement begins well before extraction.
“Many commercial honey brands enter the process at the very end as packers,” she says. “Our ‘Bloom to Bottle’ philosophy means understanding the landscape before the bees even arrive.”
For the consumer standing in front of a shelf, however, the broader lesson is simpler: honey is not necessarily supposed to behave like a perfectly standardised product.
Its appearance can change. One harvest can taste different from another. Its colour can vary, and a jar can crystallise.
Rather than judging honey solely by whether it remains clear, golden and runny, consumers can also pay attention to where it comes from, who produced it and how the honey has been handled.
Sometimes the jar that looks a little different is not telling you something has gone wrong. It is simply reminding you that honey begins with bees, flowers, weather and a particular place, not a factory recipe.
Please Share!
Newsletter
First in line for the rare harvests
Small batches, short notice. A few emails a year.